In a controversial turn of events, a tap dance rendition of “The Nutcracker” performed at the White House during the holiday season has faced heavy criticism from conservative media outlets. The short video, posted on Instagram by First Lady Jill Biden, showcases the award-winning Dorrance Dance company’s interpretation of the classic ballet. However, rather than embracing the joy and festive spirit of the performance, some individuals have taken offense to the unconventional twist on a beloved holiday tradition. Despite the backlash, it is clear that these critics are missing the point of the dance, as it celebrates marginalized art forms like tap dance and jazz, while offering a fresh and enchanting take on a timeless story.
Title
Who’s Afraid of a Tap Dance ‘Nutcracker’?
Introduction
Tap dance and jazz are deeply rooted in American culture, representing creativity, innovation, and a celebration of diversity. Recently, a video featuring a tap dance version of ‘The Nutcracker’ performed by Dorrance Dance at the White House has sparked both praise and criticism. While some have lauded the video for its joyful and inclusive representation of the art forms, conservative media outlets have voiced their disapproval. This article will explore the background of the video, the criticism it has received, the significance of tap dance and jazz in American culture, and the importance of representation in ‘The Nutcracker’.
Background Information
The White House video featuring a tap dance version of ‘The Nutcracker’
In a video posted on social media by the First Lady, Jill Biden, a group of dancers from Dorrance Dance perform a tap dance rendition of ‘The Nutcracker’. Shot at the White House for the holiday season, the video showcases the talents of the dancers and highlights the unique blend of tap dance and jazz.
The criticism from conservative media outlets
Despite the joyfulness and festive spirit portrayed in the video, conservative media outlets, including Fox News and The New York Post, have criticized the performance. These outlets argue that the video presents a dystopian and dark interpretation of ‘The Nutcracker’, straying away from its traditional portrayal.
The significance of tap dance and jazz in American culture
Tap dance and jazz hold a special place in American culture, representing the country’s rich history of creativity and innovation. Both art forms have roots in African American culture and have been used as powerful mediums for self-expression and storytelling. Understanding the historical and cultural significance of tap dance and jazz is crucial to appreciate the artistic choices made in the White House video.
The White House Video
Description of the video and its opening shot
The video begins with Josette Wiggan, a dancer from Dorrance Dance, wearing a sequined romper and exuding elegance and grace. She performs a series of intricate tap dance sequences, accompanied by the lively and dynamic music of Duke Ellington and Billy Strayhorn’s jazz arrangement of Tchaikovsky’s ‘Nutcracker’. The opening shot sets the tone for the video, showcasing the impressive talent and charisma of the performers.
The use of Duke Ellington and Billy Strayhorn’s jazz arrangement
The choice to use Duke Ellington and Billy Strayhorn’s jazz arrangement of Tchaikovsky’s ‘Nutcracker’ is significant. It unites two iconic American art forms, jazz and tap dance, while also infusing a sense of history and cultural relevance. The jazz arrangement adds a fresh and dynamic dimension to the traditional music of ‘The Nutcracker’, further highlighting the innovation and creativity present in the video.
The invitation to dance and celebration of tap dance and jazz
The video serves as an invitation to embrace and celebrate tap dance and jazz. It showcases the exuberance and infectious joy of the dancers, inviting viewers to join in the celebration. By featuring professional tap dancers, the video pays homage to the art form’s history and highlights its continued relevance and impact in American culture.
Dr. Biden’s description of the video
Dr. Jill Biden, in her post accompanying the video, describes it as a “bit of magic, wonder, and joy” brought to viewers by the talented tappers of Dorrance Dance. Her acknowledgement of the video’s playfulness further emphasizes its intended purpose, which is to bring joy and positivity during the holiday season.
Criticism of the Video
Criticism of ‘The Nutcracker’ as dystopian and dark
One of the main criticisms directed towards the video is its deviation from the traditional portrayal of ‘The Nutcracker’. Some conservative media outlets have labeled the video as dystopian and dark, claiming that it undermines the original vision of the classic ballet. However, it is important to note that ‘The Nutcracker’ has always contained fantastical and sometimes dark elements, making the video’s interpretation a valid artistic choice.
Personal criticism of Michelle Dorrance
Michelle Dorrance, the artistic director of Dorrance Dance and the choreographer of the video, has faced personal criticism from conservative media outlets. As a white woman in a traditionally Black art form, Dorrance has been the subject of scrutiny and accusations of cultural appropriation. However, Dorrance’s work has always demonstrated her respect for tap dance history and her commitment to honoring her tap dance ancestors.
Michelle Dorrance and Tap Dance
Michelle Dorrance as a white woman in a traditionally Black art form
Michelle Dorrance’s position as a white woman in a traditionally Black art form raises important questions about representation and cultural appropriation. However, Dorrance has proven herself to be a dedicated and respectful practitioner of tap dance. She acknowledges her privilege and actively engages with tap dance history, ensuring the art form’s legacy is preserved and celebrated.
Her respect for tap dance history and ancestors
In a statement on her website, Dorrance expresses her deep respect for tap dance history and her tap dance ancestors. She recognizes the struggles and achievements of Black tap dancers who paved the way for future generations. Dorrance’s commitment to honoring the art form and its legacy is reflected in the White House video and her other choreographic works.
The importance of representation in ‘The Nutcracker’
The inclusion of tap dance and jazz in ‘The Nutcracker’ is significant for representation in the arts. Traditionally, ‘The Nutcracker’ production has lacked diversity, with few opportunities for dancers of different backgrounds to be represented on stage. By integrating tap dance and jazz into the narrative, the White House video offers a more inclusive and empowering version of the story, allowing marginalized groups to see themselves represented in the world of dance.
The Holiday Tour
The tour of ‘The Nutcracker Suite’
The holiday tour of ‘The Nutcracker Suite’ by Dorrance Dance showcases the company’s commitment to spreading joy and positivity through dance. The tour aims to recognize the pain and heartache present in the world while empowering young people to become forces of good. By bringing this version of ‘The Nutcracker’ to different communities, Dorrance Dance aims to create a sense of inclusivity and shared experiences.
The recognition of pain and heartache in the world
In acknowledging the pain and heartache prevalent in the world, Dorrance Dance’s ‘Nutcracker Suite’ tour offers a nuanced perspective. It allows audiences to recognize the struggles and hardships faced by many while simultaneously providing an uplifting and empowering experience through dance. By acknowledging and addressing these emotions, the tour encourages compassion and understanding.
Empowering young people through dance
One of the primary goals of the ‘Nutcracker Suite’ tour is to empower young people. Through dance, Dorrance Dance encourages young individuals to tap into their creativity, develop self-confidence, and become agents of positive change. Dance serves as a transformative tool, allowing young people to express themselves and find strength in their unique abilities.
Creating an inclusive version of the story
By creating an inclusive version of ‘The Nutcracker’, Dorrance Dance seeks to break down barriers and ensure that all individuals can connect with the story on a personal level. The traditional portrayal of ‘The Nutcracker’ may not resonate with marginalized groups, presenting an opportunity to reimagine the narrative. By embracing tap dance and jazz, the version presented by Dorrance Dance celebrates diversity and offers a new perspective that is accessible to a broader audience.
Conclusion
The White House video featuring a tap dance rendition of ‘The Nutcracker’ offers a refreshing and inclusive interpretation of the beloved ballet. Despite criticism from some conservative media outlets, the video celebrates the richness and cultural significance of tap dance and jazz in American culture. Michelle Dorrance and Dorrance Dance’s commitment to honoring tap dance history and creating an empowering version of ‘The Nutcracker’ reinforces the importance of representation in the arts. By merging tradition with innovation, the video invites viewers to embrace the joy and transformative power of dance.
About the Author
Gia Kourlas is an esteemed dance critic for The New York Times. With a wealth of experience and knowledge in the field, Kourlas has been covering the dance scene and providing insightful commentary on various dance forms for many years.
Site Information
© 2023 The New York Times Company. For copyright information and additional details, please refer to the New York Times website. For any inquiries or feedback regarding the article, feel free to contact the site administrators through the provided contact information.
