In “‘Flora and Son’ and the Unspoken Truth About Songwriting,” Geoff Rickly, lead singer and songwriter of the band Thursday, explores the journey of songwriting as depicted in John Carney’s films. Drawing from personal experiences and encounters with renowned record producer Rick Rubin, Rickly reflects on the pressure to evolve creatively and the delicate balance between staying true to oneself and embracing change. He analyzes Carney’s previous films and the characters’ motivations, highlighting the importance of authenticity and the pursuit of artistic growth. Rickly delves into the depth of Carney’s latest film, “Flora and Son,” and the nuanced portrayals of the characters’ relationship with music. By celebrating the value of remaining an amateur in our own lives, Rickly uncovers the unspoken truth about songwriting.
Overview of ‘Flora and Son’ and the Unspoken Truth About Songwriting
The film ‘Flora and Son’, directed by John Carney, explores the world of songwriting and the unspoken truths behind it. In this thought-provoking movie, Carney delves into the influence of his previous films, the characters and their music motivations within the story, the lessons learned from the film, and the songwriting process depicted in ‘Flora and Son’. Ultimately, the film conveys a powerful message about the importance of remaining amateurs in our own lives.
The Influence of John Carney’s Films on Songwriting
Carney’s films have had a significant impact on the world of songwriting and have resonated with audiences. His first film, ‘Once’, achieved unexpected success with its heartfelt story of a musician trying to win back his lost love. The film’s authenticity and the way it trusted the audience struck a chord with songwriters and musicians alike.
However, Carney faced disappointment with his second film, ‘Begin Again’. The Hollywood movie machine had transformed the rawness and honesty of his debut into a more calculated and commercialized product. This experience mirrored the challenges that many songwriters face when working with major label machines. The film raised questions about Carney’s capabilities and whether his success with ‘Once’ was merely beginner’s luck.
Carney’s third film, ‘Sing Street’, redeemed his reputation as a filmmaker. The movie captured the hearts of audiences and critics with its portrayal of lovelorn boys and their musical aspirations. It proved that Carney could successfully make movies about musicians, but it also left the question lingering: was that all he was capable of? The critical success of ‘Sing Street’ further highlighted Carney’s potential and renewed interest in his future projects.
Despite the challenges he faced, Carney made a deliberate choice in ‘Flora and Son’ to edit weaknesses and lean into his strengths as a filmmaker. This decision paved the way for the creation of characters and narratives that resonated with audiences on a profound level.
Characters and Their Music Motivations in ‘Flora and Son’
‘Flora and Son’ revolves around the lives of three central characters and their unique motivations for pursuing music. Flora’s arrogant ex-boyfriend, Ian, sees music as a means to prioritize his own interests above others. He harbors dreams of musical stardom, despite his current setback. In contrast, Flora’s son, Max, discovers music as a way to get the attention of his crush and navigate the world of teenage insecurities.
Flora’s guitar teacher, Jeff, embodies a different approach to music. He views music as a sacred spiritual path and imparts his knowledge to Flora and Max with a sense of generosity and humility. Through these characters, the film explores the varied reasons why individuals are drawn to music and how their motivations shape their musical journeys.
Lessons Learned from ‘Flora and Son’
‘Flora and Son’ offers valuable insights and lessons about songwriting and life. Firstly, the film emphasizes the importance of finding authenticity in music. It encourages songwriters to stay true to themselves and their unique voices, rather than chasing trends or seeking validation from external sources.
Humility and a willingness to learn are also crucial aspects highlighted by the film. Both Flora’s son, Max, and her guitar teacher, Jeff, embody this humility by embracing their roles as perpetual students of music. The film underscores the importance of continuous growth and learning, even for experienced musicians.
Furthermore, ‘Flora and Son’ stands out for its portrayal of three-dimensional female characters. Flora, the flawed and complex protagonist, challenges stereotypes and offers an authentic representation of women in the music industry. The film’s exploration of Flora’s journey and her relationships is a refreshing departure from the traditional portrayal of female characters in similar narratives.
Lastly, the film encourages viewers to put their faith in music. It highlights the transformative power of music, not only in Flora and Max’s lives but also in the lives of all those who let it into their hearts. Music becomes a source of solace, hope, and inspiration for the characters, emphasizing the profound impact that it can have on individuals.
Exploring the Songwriting Process in ‘Flora and Son’
‘Flora and Son’ delves into the intricacies of the songwriting process and offers valuable insights for aspiring songwriters. Flora’s journey with the guitar serves as a metaphor for her personal growth and musical development. Her initial struggles with the instrument represent the challenges and learning curve that many songwriters face when starting their musical journeys.
One important lesson conveyed by the film is the significance of keeping the songs small and authentic. While many aspiring songwriters may dream of writing an instant hit, ‘Flora and Son’ highlights the beauty and power of crafting intimate and personal songs. Flora’s unimpressed critique of Jeff’s songs demonstrates the importance of honest feedback and the willingness to refine and improve one’s work.
The film underscores the role of listening in the songwriting process. Carney’s portrayal of Jeff as someone who deeply listens to the music around him and absorbs its nuances reinforces the idea that listening is as crucial as playing. By drawing attention to the magic of listening, the film encourages songwriters to embrace and appreciate the transformative qualities of music.
Lastly, ‘Flora and Son’ emphasizes the value of remaining an amateur. In a world that often prioritizes professional success and recognition, the film reminds audiences that the true essence of music lies in the love and passion for the craft. Staying connected to the amateur spirit allows songwriters to maintain their authenticity and continue to find joy and fulfillment in their music.
Conclusion: The Message of ‘Flora and Son’
‘Flora and Son’ delivers a powerful message about the importance of remaining amateurs in our own lives. Through the exploration of songwriting and the journeys of its characters, the film highlights the significance of authenticity, humility, and continuous learning. It challenges societal expectations of professional success while celebrating the personal growth and transformation that music can bring. Ultimately, ‘Flora and Son’ encourages viewers to embrace the amateur spirit, to stay true to themselves, and to find solace and inspiration in the world of music.
